Spring Farm Sinking Homes Saga: Neighbourhood Divided Over Collapsing Houses

Alex Proimos from Sydney, Australia | Farm Road | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Farm_Road_%285202693666%29.jpg | Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license. | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/deed.en

Homes at Spring Farm, in Sydney's south west, were built over sinking ground. As the homes continue to sink, structural damage in many of the homes is becoming increasingly worse. There are also some homes are without any structural damage.

Homeowners with damaged properties believe that the way the site was filled prior to the construction stage caused the land to move and led to dangerous and costly defects. However, unaffected property owners claim it's the builders' fault. A class action lawsuit is seeking tens of millions of dollars in damages from the developers and Camden Council.

Number of Barrels in DDT Dump Site Is Much Larger Than Scientists Expected

G.R. Sylva | Underwater view of two Navy divers. | https://picryl.com/media/underwater-view-of-two-navy-divers-working-to-raise-the-submarine-ex-uss-bluegill-636991 | No known copyright restrictions | https://catalog.archives.gov/

Researchers compared the number of barrels lying 3,000 feet under the surface of the ocean to stars in the Milky Way. The research crew documenting the dumpsite off the coast of Santa Catalina Island in California used sonar images to gather information on the dumpsite that turned out to be much larger than expected. 

It is estimated that as many as half a million barrels might be underwater according to records and a recent UC Santa Barbara Study. The area is known to be a DDT dumpsite.

The findings were shared in April 2021 in a U.S. congressional briefing led by Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), who said she plans to find out if the companies that dumped the waste can be held accountable.

Louisiana Ruling States That Legal Fees Must be Paid by Pipeline Company

The Louisiana state Constitution states that landowners who lose property from eminent domain must be fully compensated, and a ruling from the Supreme Court now says that compensation includes paying for the landowner’s attorney and legal fees.

The ruling comes from a dispute over the Bayou Bridge Pipeline being built through landowners’ property. In 2018 the company was sued for building the 163-mile pipeline through a 38-acre piece of land in St. Martin Parish without paying landowners compensation for the land taken.  Bayou Bridge Pipeline LLC, the company building the pipeline, has already paid around $30,000 in damages to landowners and now must pay more money to landowners to cover legal fees.

This ruling is the first time the state’s high court has held that the Constitution permits litigation and attorney costs as an element of just compensation to landowners in eminent domain proceedings.

Continued Legal Action Against Limetree Bay Refinery

G.jenewein | Die Costa Concordia beim Abwracken im Hafen von Genua (September 2015) | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Costa_Concordia_Abwracken.jpg | Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license. | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en

Lee J. Rohn and Associates is now the third law firm in one week to file a class-action lawsuit against Limetree Bay Refinery seeking recompense for oil sprays and noxious emissions. As of May 21, 2021, over 200 residents have signed up as part of the class action.

The legal brief includes personal injuries and property damage from “unreasonable odors, gases, vapors, and fumes because of Defendants conduct in operating the Limetree Bay Refinery”. The brief also alleges the refinery to be “a blight and nuisance” that lowers the property values of residents in the area. The brief also argues that the medical monitoring and continual screening for illness causes a diminution in the value of their homes and other real properties.

The EPA published a report stating that the refinery has exceeded the emission standard for harmful chemicals multiple times, and at one time was 565 times higher than the emission standard. The EPA has investigated the refinery and found a lack of monitors for the release of chemicals. This class action also seeks an injunction that might go beyond the EPA’s says, attorney Lee J. Rohn.

Two other law firms have filed class-action lawsuits against the company seeking compensation for loss of use and enjoyment of properties.

One Year After the Atlantic Richfield Company v. Christian Ruling

Bureau of Land Management | Bureau of Land Management | https://picryl.com/media/-conservationlands15-social-media-takeover-may-15th-blm-montana-and-partners-3b023e | Public Domain Creative Commons License | http://commons.wikimedia.org/

One year after the ruling in which 98 Montana landowners within the boundary of a Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (“CERCLA”) Superfund site, sought compensation in state court relating to pollution damage to their properties.

Part of the damages sought were “restoration” damages which were intended to completely restore properties to the condition prior to contamination. Montana is the only state that recognizes restoration damages.

The Supreme Court of Montana restated that the United States Supreme Court’s ruling that Atlantic Richfield may be liable for the landowners’ remediation beyond what is required under CERCLA; however, the landowners need to obtain EPA approval for the remedial work. All further work that Atlantic Richfield may be liable for needs to be authorized by the EPA.

This ruling potentially broadens the ability to challenge an EPA clean-up and it defined the scope of federal jurisdiction under CERCLA.

Homeowners Win Lawsuit Over Property Damage From Japanese Knotweed

Residents in Carmarthenshire, England won £42,500 in compensations for damages from Japanese Knotweed, an invasive plant known for causing structural damages by growing into cracks and joints of drain pipes.

Residents reached out to the Network Rail years ago when they noticed the plants, but the company was not responsive to them. Residents sued the Network Rail for the encroachment of the invasive plant on their properties. Joann Cameron, a litigation executive at High Street Solicitors stated that: “Japanese Knotweed can cause damage to a property dependent upon how severe it is.”

$11.9 Million Settlement Reached in Parchment, Michigan Drinking Water Lawsuit

Defense Visual Information Distribution Service | Master Sgt. Pedro Rodriguez with the 177th fighter. | https://picryl.com/media/master-sgt-pedro-rodriguez-with-the-177th-fighter-c23e9a | Public Domain Dedication. Public Use Notice of Limitations | https://www.dvidshub.net/about/copyright

In November 2018, a complaint was filed against 3M and Georgia-Pacific. The complaint claimed PFAS chemicals had migrated into the Parchment, Michigan drinking water supply from a former paper mill and its associated facilities. The complaint sought monetary damages for diminished property value, property damage, interference with use and enjoyment of property, stigma damages, and medical monitoring from exposure to PFAS.

A settlement of $11.9 million was reached in April 2021. The settlement class included anyone who owned, leased, rented, or resided in homes or residential properties serviced by the Parchment water system as of July 26, 2018, but has not brought individual actions for illness or personal injury based on PFAS exposure.

Letters Warning Residents in Denham Springs, Louisiana of Flood Mitigation Efforts

Defense Visual Information Distribution Service | Flooded areas of Baton Rouge, Louisiana, are shown | https://garystockbridge617.getarchive.net/amp/media/flooded-areas-of-baton-rouge-louisiana-are-shown-960e43 | Public Domain Dedication. Public Use Notice of Limitations | https://www.dvidshub.net/about/copyright

Some of the homes on Wolf Creek Place that were flooded by about 6 feet of water in 2016 have been gutted and repaired. After the flood, homeowners in Denham Springs, Louisiana received letters earlier this month warning them about the need for flood mitigation that includes tearing down the structure or raising the property. Around 1,221 homeowners in the area are affected.

Homeowners are concerned about who will be paying for the mitigation efforts. FEMA will pay for 75% of the cost of the mitigation efforts through a grant. However, only so much money becomes available every year, so people can be on the grant list for years before receiving funds. Homes that are not mitigated will remain listed as substantially damaged and homeowners will be required to disclose this information to potential buyers. Homeowners have the option to file an appeal to the Livingston Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness.

House Explosion in Hamilton, Canada

On April 16, 2021, an explosion leveled a home and damaged 3 others on Bonaventure Drive in Hamilton, Canada. A large debris field was left on the property when fire crews arrived at the scene and they reported a strong odor of natural gas. The gas service was subsequently shut down and 8 neighboring homes were evacuated. Investigators estimated that the damages are around $1 million.

The Pollution Plumes of the North Pole

Matti&Keti | North Pole, Arctic Ocean, sea ice | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:North_Pole,_Arctic_Ocean,_sea_ice_04.jpg | Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license. | https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en

On April 19, 2021, an oil refining chemical infiltrated the water of a small Alaskan town. A chemical solvent called sulfolane had spilled, contaminating the groundwater.

Sulfolane is an industrial solvent used in more than 150 locations around the world, including refineries in California, Texas, and Puerto Rico. Its human health impacts are not yet well-studied. In limited animal studies high exposures has caused hyperactivity and convulsions, developmental and reproductive problems, and death.

Linda Brown’s family finished drilling a water well, four days later they turned on the evening news to see images of an oil refinery a mile from their trailer. The Brown’s water was later tested, indicating 283 parts per billion (ppb) of sulfolane, well above the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) regional screening level of 20 ppb.

PFAS Action Introduced in Congress

pixabay.com | A dog drinking water from a bowl | https://jenikirbyhistory.getarchive.net/media/chihuahua-dog-chiwawa-animals-856093 | Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication license | https://web.archive.org/web/20161229043156/https://pixabay.com/en/service/terms/

On April 13, 2021 Reps. Debbie Dingell (D) and Fred Upton (R), introduced the PFAS Action Act of 2021. The Act creates a national drinking water standard for PFAS chemicals and designates PFAS as hazardous substances. This enables the Environmental Protection Agency to establish regulatory limits and require cleanup of sites that exceed such limits in drinking water.

PFAS chemicals are man-made chemicals that are linked to health effects such as cancer and reproductive and developmental harms. PFAS is found in the drinking water of more than 2,000 communities. The Act also requires the EPA to place discharge limits on industrial releases of PFAS and provide $200 million annually for wastewater treatment.

Luxury Condo Building Flooded in Vancouver

Guilhem Vellut from Vancouver, Canada | Downtown Vancouver July 2011 | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Downtown_Vancouver_July_2011.jpg | Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_Commons

On April 15, 2021 water from an upper floor of a luxury condo building called the Vancouver House, in Vancouver, British Columbia, flooded and left the elevators inoperable. The developer stated that the cause of the water leak was a gasket failure and plans have been made to replace all gaskets of the model that failed. Damages to the units are being assessed to determine if residents have to move out for the repairs to be completed.

Pending Litigation Over Laguna Beach Home Renovations

Beyond My Ken | Houses in south Laguna Beach hills | https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Houses_in_south_Laguna_Beach_hills.jpg | Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International, 3.0 Unported, 2.5 Generic, 2.0 Generic and 1.0 Generic license. | https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_Commons

In early February 2021 the Laguna Beach Historic Preservation Coalition and Historic Architecture Alliance filed a lawsuit against the city of Laguna Beach regarding the remodel of a single-family residence location at 369 Hawthorne Road. The lawsuit requires the city to set aside approvals for the home’s renovation projects and reconsider approval after “adequate environmental review and full compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act” have been met.

The lawsuit alleges that the city violated CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act) mandates when the remodel was approved and that the project does not meet standards set forth by the Secretary of the Interior. The owners of the house claim that they followed the steps outlined by the city and were very meticulous throughout the remodel process so far. The plans for the home include an addition of 1,020 square feet to the 1925 single-family residence. This disagreement began in 2017 when the home was purchased by the current owners.

Australian Residents Seek Compensation for Metro Tunnel Under Their Homes

Residents in Yarraville, Australia have taken legal action seeking up to 10% of the value of the address in compensation for a metro tunnel being dug under their homes. Adrian McMillain, a lawyer for the case states that “It comes down to the pretty basic question, ‘Would you rather buy a house that was above a tunnel or one that wasn’t above a tunnel?’.

Jacinta Allan, the Transport Infrastructure Minister, has stated that the prices of homes on these tunnels have been unaffected due to the tunnel being dug at least 15 meters underground. Michael O’Brien, the Opposition Leader, stated that the landowners should be fairly compensated if projects impact the property’s value.

McMillain claims market evidence suggests that there is a diminution in the value for the properties above this tunnel. McMillain also claims that property owners are entitled to the land to the center of the earth because the owners all have titles created before December 1891. Therefore, they are entitled to compensation for the taking of the land.

Disneyland Looks To Repurpose Real Estate At California Theme Park

Disney is looking to densify and repurpose its real estate. On March 28, 2021, Disneyland Resort in Anaheim, California announces that it is looking to redesign and expand its theme park, retail, and parking real estate in the coming decades.

Officials say the overall footprint of the Anaheim park is not expected to change as long-range concept plans are calling generally to redevelop underutilized parking lots and other spaces near the park’s rides and on-site hotels.

Among the ideas pitched on Disney's conceptual blueprint called "Disneyland Forward" are restaurants, hotels, live music, shopping, ticketed shows, and theme park experiences modeled after the popular Disney Springs at Walt Disney World Resort, an open-air promenade with more than 100 places to shop, eat and drink.

Record Rains Cause Flash Flooding in Tennessee

This image is from the FEMA Photo Library | Aerial of Flooding in Tennessee | https://garystockbridge617.getarchive.net/amp/media/fema-43944-aerial-of-flooding-in-tennessee-786307 | Public Domain | http://commons.wikimedia.org/

On March 28, 2021, torrential rains across Tennessee flooded homes and at least one church. A portion of Interstate 40 was temporarily shut down due to high water and first responders also told drivers to avoid part of I-24 south of Nashville.

Over 34 swift water rescues were carried out and as many as 18 homes in one neighborhood had to be evacuated. Three men and one woman have been found dead.

While there was no longer any precipitation falling, flooding remained a threat as authorities expect rivers to continue to rise.

Office: 33971 Selva Road, Suite 230, Dana Point, CA 92629
Phone: 949.497.7603     Fax: 949.497.7601